Really enjoyed this book, felt as if i was in the thick of battle. Could not put it down. Gripping accounts of fighting the enemy ill equipped and low on ammo. Brave men, exciting and heartbreaking accounts of battle.
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: New
Military historian and retired Royal Marines Lieutenant Colonel Ewen Southby-Tailyour has written in 3 Commando Brigade, a rather dry and uninteresting book that I would generously characterise as modest in its' retelling of events in Helmand Province, Afghanistan, 2006. In the author's notes at the end of the book, Southby-Tailyour thanks a colleague in helping to shape his manuscript "... into something more appealing to a wider audience... from 'niche market' to 'mass market'." This was not achieved. 3 Commando Brigade remains the work of a military historian. Perhaps this book will become invaluable as a source for future historians but as a book in its' own right, it does not succeed. There is no dramatic narrative to this book, though perhaps that is the author's intention - to remove any 'glamour' from the awful truth of the battlefield. However, neither are there any strong characters to this book. Names occasionally repeat but not to the point of familiarity, stories are told and fragments of scenes are depicted but nothing really holds together. Firefights that take hours are skimmed over rapidly. The book becomes self-limited as a collection of disjointed non-linear recollections and quotes. Despite the author, one still leaves this book with a tremendous admiration for the determination of the soldiers involved, though also quite strongly, that they are achieving next to nothing out there. Hills are 'taken' and compounds are 'cleared' and these operations are deemed a 'success' by those in command but there certainly seems to be an underlying acknowledgment that what the marines have done will not last, that their achievements are ultimately transient. To be brutally honest i would not recommend this book, as to get a true picture of what it was like to be a footsoldier on the frontline of Afghanistan you will not be enlightened!Read full review
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Best Selling in Textbooks
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Save on Textbooks