 |
How does a people survive while being hunted down like animals by the Nazis, having no one to turn to due to Nazi collaborators, and no one to trust like the Soviet army who were the enemy of their enemy (the Nazis)? That's the situation that be fronted the The Bielski partisans, four Jewish brothers in 1941 Eastern (Nazi occupied ) Poland. Tuvia (Daniel Craig) and his three brothers Zus (Liev Schreiber), Asael (Jamie Bell), and Aron (George MacKay) elluded the Nazis and their collaborators who confined the Jews to ghettos before sending them to the extermination camps. Tuvia, their leader, shelters a growing number of Jewish escapees from the ghettos whom they encounter in the forest. The forest was their only friend which provided the shelter and cover they needed. This is their story and how they along with 1200 other Jewish people survived. I saw it as sort of a retelling of the Exodus story on a smaller scale but having its obvious parallels, like building their shelters reminded me of Sukkot, and the marsh scene which echoed the crossing of the Reed Sea but with a much different twist. Instead of the desert wilderness of the Sinai, its the forest which in many ways can be just as inhospitable to those who've never taken to the forest. Thus, Tuvia became a sort of Moses figure who must not only deal with the Nazis, the Soviets (his questionable allies), and local antisemitic countrymen, but also the squabbling, bickering, and arguing amongst the very people he was trying to protect and rescue. Craig and Schreiber offer a fine performance in their roles as the two brothers who were at odds with each other but learn what it is to be human in an inhumane world. The video transfer is pristine. It is full of subtle and fine details even in darker scenes. When Tuvia held the mezuzah in his palm, I could see the weather beaten intricate details still engraved upon it. The colors during the less dark scenes like in the forest during daylight were about as natural as can be captured on film. I commend Eduardo Serra for his excellent cinematography in every situation, indoors and outdoors that really enhance the mood of the scene. The lossless TrueHD audio track delivered fairly good sound. I enjoyed hearing the quiet yet quite distinct enviromental sounds found in a forest, too numerous to list, but they're all there. At the other end of the scale loud sounds from the canon fire from German tanks or bombs dropped from German aircraft were mediocre and sounded a bit subdued. It was as though DRC was turned on. However that wasn't the case since both my BD player and receiver are never on Auto but always set to wide dynamic range. The dynamic impact of the explosions just weren't that realistic. The rest of the audio is quite good though. The dialogue is right on the mark, very clear and easy to follow. The music score and theme were absolutely delightful. The overall sound quality was very satisfactory, although not excellent and certainly not reference quality. The extra features will acquaint the viewer with how the film was made, some of Zwick's insights, and how it compared historically to the actual events and lots more. It's true Zwick added some hollywood style embellishments to make it more thrilling like overdoing the combat scenes which perhaps was necessary to provide more funding. History buffs will definitely want to add this BD to their collection. All others will want to give it a rent before buying. Defiance iRead full review
I really enjoy the movies of Edward Zwick ("Glory," "Last Samurai," "Blood Diamond")- and this movie is also highly enjoyable. Once again, I believe the critics are crazy for bashing "Defiance." I personally enjoyed it much better than I did some of the Oscar- contenders that were over- hyped by the critics (like "Revolutionary Road" and "The Reader"). Like his other movies, I classify "Defiance" as dramatic- action. There's never a dull moment and you become emotionally invested with the characters. While Daniel Craig is definitely excellent in the lead role, I think the movie belongs to Liev Schreiber, who brings an incredible range of emotion to his role. The PQ is absolutely wonderful: This isn't a "colorful" movie by any means- colors do not explode from the screen and are actually rather drab. However, blacks are very deep which enhance the primary colors (blues, browns and greens) The colors of the forest "pop" from the screen, and the winter scenes with falling snow are simply incredible. Since nearly the entire film takes place in the wild, the landscapes are filmed beautifully. Good acting... Good action... beautiful PQ... what's not to like? Well, apparently the so- called "history buffs" are crawling out of the woodwork and panning the movie for not being historically accurate (read some of the ridiculous posts for "Defiance" at IMDB.com and you'll see what I mean). So, History Buffs, Beware: this movie, which is a FICTIONAL take on real- life events, is NOT a documentary on the History Channel. If you want to hate on this movie because it is historically innacurate, then why bother watching historical movies at all? 99.9% of them aren't historically accurate, either. (I think the most historically accurate movie I've seen was "Gettysburg," which I consider a classic and is far superior to its mediocre sequel "Gods & Generals") That being said, there are some good suppliments on the BD discussing the history behind the movie. If you like Zwick's previous movies, this one is a no- brainer. However, if you an... ulp... history professor wannabe, then probably stick to renting this one.Read full review
Saw this before and had to own it!! Brave people fighting for survival is an inspiration!
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: New
It is a. great story of the will to survive.
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
True unbelievable story
Verified purchase: Yes | Condition: Pre-owned
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Best Selling in DVDs & Blu-ray Discs
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Save on DVDs & Blu-ray Discs
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- You may also like
