Reviews
"Scholarly and eminently readable, this book commends itself to both scholars and non-scholars across disciplines. While analysing the debates about 'family' that proliferated in the Tamil region of India during the late 19th century and the mid-20th century, it examines the claims about the family -- its appropriate membership, its role in buttressing 'culture' and 'tradition', and the property relations of its members -- that, according to the author, became critical to the formulation and contestation of Tamil social relations." -- The Hindu, Dec. 22, 2009, "Rather than settling on one conception of the family, Sreenivas tracks how ideals changed over time through very public debates in Tamil society. She does not settle for quick or easy answers about family values and demonstrates how different social groups engaged the question to advance their interests in political and economic spheres." -- DURBA GHOSH, Cornell University, USA, Gender and History, Vol. 21.2 August 2009, The Zemindar used to take his meals with me. The Zemindar used to sleep during nights in the upstairs of the new palace. I and he used to sleep in the same bed., "Sreenivas's study is, without a doubt, a 'must read' for scholars interested in the history of the family, women and gender, as well as the development of anti-colonial nationalist politics. Her careful historicization of the 'family' as an equally powerful force alongside the 'nation,' and the many qualifications to Chatterjee's influential work that this approach pulls into the foreground makes 'Widows, Wives and Concubines' an invaluable addition to both Indian social history and colonial studies." -Journal of Colonialism and Colonial History, Vol. 10.3 Winter 20009, "Overall, this book is a valuable addition in the list of historical research works on the issues of women, community politics and colonial legislative ventures in southern India. The research related strength of the book is that it draws information from a variety of primary sources, ranging from archives of court cases, women's narratives and women's writings in the magazines. The author, in a very articulate manner, simplifies the complex history of family, politics, caste, class and economic pressures in Tamil Nadu." -Human Rights and Human Welfare, 2009, This is . . . a well-researched, theoretically informed and stylistically refined study of the articulation of a new--the conjugal--family ideal in colonial India.Vol. 114. 4 Oct. 2009, Sreenivas's study is, without a doubt, a 'must read' for scholars interested in the history of the family, women and gender, as well as the development of anti-colonial nationalist politics. Her careful historicization of the 'family' as an equally powerful force alongside the 'nation,' and the many qualifications to Chatterjee's influential work that this approach pulls into the foreground makes 'Widows, Wives and Concubines' an invaluable addition to both Indian social history and colonial studies., This is... a well-researched, theoretically informed and stylistically refined study of the articulation of a new--the conjugal--family ideal in colonial India.--SUDHIR CHANDRA, Mizoram University"American Historical Review" (01/01/2009), Colonial voices fromWives, Widows, and Concubines:"The Zemindar used to take his meals with me. The Zemindar used to sleep during nights in the upstairs of the new palace. I and he used to sleep in the same bed." Menakshi Sundra Nachiar, 1893"Whenever my husband felt amorous, he would occasionally cohabit with any woman and pay her occasionally. This is all. They were concubines." Muthuverammal, 1885"The very principle of the joint family is against giving equal rights to females." P. C. Tyagaraja Iyer, 1935, "Sreenivas's discussion points to the importance for feminist scholarship of exploring the links among conjugality, kinship, and capitalisms both historically and today." -Feminist Formations, Rather than settling on one conception of the family, Sreenivas tracks how ideals changed over time through very public debates in Tamil society. She does not settle for quick or easy answers about family values and demonstrates how different social groups engaged the question to advance their interests in political and economic spheres., "The Zemindar used to take his meals with me. The Zemindar used to sleep during nights in the upstairs of the new palace. I and he used to sleep in the same bed." -- Menakshi Sundra Nachiar, 1893, "This volume about the changing family in colonial South India is a welcome addition to the literature on marriage and family." -The Journal of Asian Studies, Volume 69/1, February 2010, "Scholarly and eminently readable, this book commends itself to both scholars and non-scholars across disciplines. While analysing the debates about 'family' that proliferated in the Tamil region of India during the late 19th century and the mid-20th century, it examines the claims about the family - its appropriate membership, its role in buttressing 'culture' and 'tradition', and the property relations of its members - that, according to the author, became critical to the formulation and contestation of Tamil social relations." -The Hindu, Dec. 22, 2009, "The Zemindar used to take his meals with me. The Zemindar used to sleep during nights in the upstairs of the new palace. I and he used to sleep in the same bed." -Menakshi Sundra Nachiar, 1893, "Overall, this book is a valuable addition in the list of historical research works on the issues of women, community politics and colonial legislative ventures in southern India. The research related strength of the book is that it draws information from a variety of primary sources, ranging from archives of court cases, women's narratives and women's writings in the magazines. The author, in a very articulate manner, simplifies the complex history of family, politics, caste, class and economic pressures in Tamil Nadu." -- Human Rights and Human Welfare, 2009, "Sreenivas's study is, without a doubt, a 'must read' for scholars interested in the history of the family, women and gender, as well as the development of anti-colonial nationalist politics. Her careful historicization of the 'family' as an equally powerful force alongside the 'nation,' and the many qualifications to Chatterjee's influential work that this approach pulls into the foreground makes 'Widows, Wives and Concubines' an invaluable addition to both Indian social history and colonial studies." -- Journal of Colonialism and Colonial History, Vol. 10.3 Winter 20009, Sreenivas's discussion points to the importance for feminist scholarship of exploring the links among conjugality, kinship, and capitalisms both historically and today., This volume about the changing family in colonial South India is a welcome addition to the literature on marriage and family., Overall, this book is a valuable addition in the list of historical research works on the issues of women, community politics and colonial legislative ventures in southern India. The research related strength of the book is that it draws information from a variety of primary sources, ranging from archives of court cases, women's narratives and women's writings in the magazines. The author, in a very articulate manner, simplifies the complex history of family, politics, caste, class and economic pressures in Tamil Nadu., "This volume about the changing family in colonial South India is a welcome addition to the literature on marriage and family." -- The Journal of Asian Studies, Volume 69/1, February 2010, "Overall, this book is a valuable addition in the list of historical research works on the issues of women, community politics and colonial legislative ventures in southern India. The research related strength of the book is that it draws information from a variety of primary sources, ranging from archives of court cases, women's narratives and women's writings in the magazines. The author, in a very articulate manner, simplifies the complex history of family, politics, caste, class and economic pressures in Tamil Nadu.2009"-- Human Rights and Human Welfare "Sreenivas's study is, without a doubt, a 'must read' for scholars interested in the history of the family, women and gender, as well as the development of anti-colonial nationalist politics. Her careful historicization of the 'family' as an equally powerful force alongside the 'nation,' and the many qualifications to Chatterjee's influential work that this approach pulls into the foreground makes 'Widows, Wives and Concubines' an invaluable addition to both Indian social history and colonial studies. Vol. 10.3 Winter 20009"-- Journal of Colonialism and Colonial History "This volume about the changing family in colonial South India is a welcome addition to the literature on marriage and family.Volume 69/1, February 2010"-- The Journal of Asian Studies "Sreenivas's discussion points to the importance for feminist scholarship of exploring the links among conjugality, kinship, and capitalisms both historically and today."-- Feminist Formations "Scholarly and eminently readable, this book commends itself to both scholars and non-scholars across disciplines. While analysing the debates about 'family' that proliferated in the Tamil region of India during the late 19th century and the mid-20th century, it examines the claims about the family -- its appropriate membership, its role in buttressing 'culture' and 'tradition', and the property relations of its members -- that, according to the author, became critical to the formulation and contestation of Tamil social relations.Dec. 22, 2009"-- The Hindu "This is . . . a well-researched, theoretically informed and stylistically refined study of the articulation of a new--the conjugal--family ideal in colonial India.Vol. 114. 4 Oct. 2009"--SUDHIR CHANDRA, Mizoram University "Rather than settling on one conception of the family, Sreenivas tracks how ideals changed over time through very public debates in Tamil society. She does not settle for quick or easy answers about family values and demonstrates how different social groups engaged the question to advance their interests in political and economic spheres.Vol. 21.2 August 2009"--DURBA GHOSH, Cornell University, USA "Whenever my husband felt amorous, he would occasionally cohabit with any woman and pay her occasionally. This is all. They were concubines."--Muthuverammal, 1885 "The very principle of the joint family is against giving equal rights to females."--P. C. Tyagaraja Iyer, 1935 "The Zemindar used to take his meals with me. The Zemindar used to sleep during nights in the upstairs of the new palace. I and he used to sleep in the same bed."--Menakshi Sundra Nachiar, 1893, "Rather than settling on one conception of the family, Sreenivas tracks how ideals changed over time through very public debates in Tamil society. She does not settle for quick or easy answers about family values and demonstrates how different social groups engaged the question to advance their interests in political and economic spheres." -DURBA GHOSH, Cornell University, USA, Gender and History, Vol. 21.2 August 2009, Scholarly and eminently readable, this book commends itself to both scholars and non-scholars across disciplines. While analysing the debates about 'family' that proliferated in the Tamil region of India during the late 19th century and the mid-20th century, it examines the claims about the family - its appropriate membership, its role in buttressing 'culture' and 'tradition', and the property relations of its members - that, according to the author, became critical to the formulation and contestation of Tamil social relations., "This is... a well-researched, theoretically informed and stylistically refined study of the articulation of a new-the conjugal-family ideal in colonial India." -SUDHIR CHANDRA, Mizoram University, American Historical Review, Vol. 114. 4 Oct. 2009, "The very principle of the joint family is against giving equal rights to females." -P. C. Tyagaraja Iyer, 1935, "The very principle of the joint family is against giving equal rights to females." -- P. C. Tyagaraja Iyer, 1935, Whenever my husband felt amorous, he would occasionally cohabit with any woman and pay her occasionally. This is all. They were concubines., This is... a well-researched, theoretically informed and stylistically refined study of the articulation of a new-the conjugal-family ideal in colonial India., "Whenever my husband felt amorous, he would occasionally cohabit with any woman and pay her occasionally. This is all. They were concubines." -Muthuverammal, 1885, Colonial voices from Wives, Widows, and Concubines: "The Zemindar used to take his meals with me. The Zemindar used to sleep during nights in the upstairs of the new palace. I and he used to sleep in the same bed." Menakshi Sundra Nachiar, 1893 "Whenever my husband felt amorous, he would occasionally cohabit with any woman and pay her occasionally. This is all. They were concubines." Muthuverammal, 1885 "The very principle of the joint family is against giving equal rights to females." P. C. Tyagaraja Iyer, 1935"Sreenivas's discussion points to the importance for feminist scholarship of exploring the links among conjugality, kinship, and capitalisms both historically and today." Feminist Formations, Fall 2012, "This is... a well-researched, theoretically informed and stylistically refined study of the articulation of a new -- the conjugal -- family ideal in colonial India." -- SUDHIR CHANDRA, Mizoram University, American Historical Review, Vol. 114. 4 Oct. 2009, Colonial voices from Wives, Widows, and Concubines : "The Zemindar used to take his meals with me. The Zemindar used to sleep during nights in the upstairs of the new palace. I and he used to sleep in the same bed." Menakshi Sundra Nachiar, 1893 "Whenever my husband felt amorous, he would occasionally cohabit with any woman and pay her occasionally. This is all. They were concubines." Muthuverammal, 1885 "The very principle of the joint family is against giving equal rights to females." P. C. Tyagaraja Iyer, 1935, "Whenever my husband felt amorous, he would occasionally cohabit with any woman and pay her occasionally. This is all. They were concubines." -- Muthuverammal, 1885
