 |
Writing a book for the general public, especially in such a diverse culture as the USA, is a daunting task. Robert Whitaker has done a really good job of it. The topic, America's view of the mentally ill and the way they've been dealt with, is a big topic, but he did a good job of pointing out the historical beginnings, why they had such impact, what caused this attitude or that approach to become popular or die out, where we're at today, etc. Although the book is very well reseacrhed & supported, it's easy to read. It doesn't have a pompous, scholarly tone that puts you to sleep: no, it reads almost conversationally. You can tell the author is sympathetic, both to the patients and to those who wanted to help them, but where injustice is done he calls it exactly like it is. He offers realistic suggestions of how to improve on some things. After reading the book, I felt unafraid of the mentally ill: not foolishly unafraid of a real danger, but I felt I'd had my ignorance replaced with understanding & compassion. I'd be pleased & honored to have Robert Whitaker as a neighbor. I'd be even more pleased if his attitude & suggestions were to become the norm for treatment of the "feeble-minded".Read full review
Thought provoking and adamant, albeit a bit biased, exploration of the largely unexamined history of the treatment of the mentally ill in America over the last several hundred years. Stimulated lively discussion concerning the efficacy of modern treatments and the not-too-distant possibility of psychologists being able to prescribe medications. Helped put our treatment of the mentally ill in a larger historical context. Controversial & challenging!
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Best Selling in Books
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Save on Books
Current slide {CURRENT_SLIDE} of {TOTAL_SLIDES}- You may also like
