Reviews
"In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "How exciting is this? The book tackles the good, the bad and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes."--Afropunk.com "A fantastic book"--AOL Noisecreep "Thoughtful and inspiring"-- Publishers Weekly "Dawes uses her sociological smarts to remind us that metal isn't just disenfranchised white dudes' music... it's a way for all of us on the outside to feel the power."-- Revolver [4/5 stars] "Excellent"--About.com "Essential reading for those who have never felt the blow of intolerance, and for those who have felt it far too often...its themes are universal"--PopMatters "As the title suggests, Dawes has a compellingly idiosyncratic tale to tell about cultural identity and personal passion...[her] understandable difficulty is precisely what makes her struggle interesting."-- The Atlantic "Dawes has done the metal scene a great service...an important addition to every metal fan's bookshelf"--MSN.com "Laina Dawes' What Are You Doing Here? is a strikingly more powerful, penetrating, and passionate look at metal than the one written by the guy [Tony Iommi] who arguably invented the genre...brave, engaging, and unique"-- The Onion A/V Club "The book is half love letter to both black women who have paved the way and continue to pave the way, as well as the music that brought them there, and half unflinching real talk of the all unfortunate actualities of the casual to the not-so-casual racism that is embedded with the scene."--Persephone Magazine "This book needs to be mandatory reading for every new metal head."--Metal Army America "A wonderfully intimate memoir...critical insight abounds"-- Philadelphia City Paper "The women presented in What Are You Doing Here? are courageous, honest and without pretense--just like the best metal that ultimately unites them."--Albert Mudrian, editor-in-chief, Decibel "She presents metal as a source of joy, an outlet for negative emotions, a physical release and catharsis. It is also an opportunity to embrace something that Dawes, and the women she interviews, love intensely, and therefore is also the narrative of the triumph of truth and happiness over the pressure of public perception."-- Toronto Standard "Dawes brings a lot of experience, clear and concise writing and good journalism, and while she doesn't have any long-term solutions for bridging these deep and unfortunate valleys--through no fault of her own--she has still introduced the first step, which is opening our eyes and starting a dialogue."-- SLUG, "Courageous, honest, and without pretense"--Albert Mudrian, Decibel "Laina Dawes' What Are You Doing Here? is a strikingly more powerful, penetrating, and passionate look at metal than the one written by the guy [Tony Iommi] who arguably invented the genre...brave, engaging, and unique"-- The Onion A/V Club "What Are You Doing Here? is essential reading for those who have never felt the blow of intolerance, and for those who have felt it far too often."--PopMatters "As the title suggests, Dawes has a compellingly idiosyncratic tale to tell about cultural identity and personal passion...[her] understandable difficulty is precisely what makes her struggle interesting." --The Atlantic "Dawes has done the metal scene a great service, showing everyone that there's still a lot of work to do towards making metal truly welcoming to anyone who's interested in the music. We're not quite there yet, but What Are You Doing Here? is an excellent start, an important addition to every metal fan's bookshelf."--MSN.com "Thoughtful and inspiring"-- Publishers Weekly "Though focused on metal, these insights are relevant to anyone interested in how racism and sexism can impact any micro-community."-- Philadelphia City Paper "Has the force of a powerful, eloquent typhoon... What Are You Doing Here? is fearless."-- Toronto Standard "The good, the bad, and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes."-- Afro-Punk "[An] excellent new book"--heavymetal.about.com "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "A fantastic book."--AOL Noisecreep, "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal." -- Vice, "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "How exciting is this? The book tackles the good, the bad and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes."--Afropunk.com "A fantastic book"--AOL Noisecreep "Thoughtful and inspiring"-- Publishers Weekly "As journalist Laina Dawes has investigated in her 2012 book What Are You Doing Here? , women of colour have been especially marginalised by heavy metal's hyper-masculine, white-dude culture."-- The Guardian "Dawes uses her sociological smarts to remind us that metal isn't just disenfranchised white dudes' music... it's a way for all of us on the outside to feel the power."-- Revolver [4/5 stars] "Excellent"--About.com "Essential reading for those who have never felt the blow of intolerance, and for those who have felt it far too often...its themes are universal"--PopMatters "As the title suggests, Dawes has a compellingly idiosyncratic tale to tell about cultural identity and personal passion...[her] understandable difficulty is precisely what makes her struggle interesting."-- The Atlantic "Dawes has done the metal scene a great service...an important addition to every metal fan's bookshelf"--MSN.com "Laina Dawes' What Are You Doing Here? is a strikingly more powerful, penetrating, and passionate look at metal than the one written by the guy [Tony Iommi] who arguably invented the genre...brave, engaging, and unique"-- The Onion A/V Club "While the book is extensively researched and brings in a broad array of opinions from musicians, fans and academics, the most resonant moments can be found within Dawes' own history."--Spinner "Insightful and provocative."-- NOW Toronto "The book is half love letter to both black women who have paved the way and continue to pave the way, as well as the music that brought them there, and half unflinching real talk of the all unfortunate actualities of the casual to the not-so-casual racism that is embedded with the scene."--Persephone Magazine "This book needs to be mandatory reading for every new metal head."--Metal Army America "A wonderfully intimate memoir...critical insight abounds"-- Philadelphia City Paper "The women presented in What Are You Doing Here? are courageous, honest and without pretense--just like the best metal that ultimately unites them."--Albert Mudrian, editor-in-chief, Decibel "An intriguing reminder of how much we all want, need and deserve to belong to something that stimulates and validates us."-- Terrorizer "Dawes tells an important story well and gives voice to the many black girls and women who are brave enough to let themselves be different."-- LEO Weekly "She presents metal as a source of joy, an outlet for negative emotions, a physical release and catharsis. It is also an opportunity to embrace something that Dawes, and the women she interviews, love intensely, and therefore is also the narrative of the triumph of truth and happiness over the pressure of public perception."-- Toronto Standard "Dawes brings a lot of experience, clear and concise writing and good journalism, and while she doesn't have any long-term solutions for bridging these deep and unfortunate valleys--through no fault of her own--she has still introduced the first step, which is opening our eyes and starting a dialogue."-- SLUG, "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."— Vice "How exciting is this? The book tackles the good, the bad and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes."—Afropunk.com "A fantastic book"—AOL Noisecreep "Thoughtful and inspiring"— Publishers Weekly "As journalist Laina Dawes has investigated in her 2012 book What Are You Doing Here? , women of colour have been especially marginalised by heavy metal''s hyper-masculine, white-dude culture."— The Guardian "Dawes uses her sociological smarts to remind us that metal isn''t just disenfranchised white dudes'' music... it''s a way for all of us on the outside to feel the power."— Revolver [4/5 stars] "Excellent"—About.com "Essential reading for those who have never felt the blow of intolerance, and for those who have felt it far too often...its themes are universal"—PopMatters "As the title suggests, Dawes has a compellingly idiosyncratic tale to tell about cultural identity and personal passion…[her] understandable difficulty is precisely what makes her struggle interesting."— The Atlantic "Dawes has done the metal scene a great service...an important addition to every metal fan's bookshelf"—MSN.com "Laina Dawes' What Are You Doing Here? is a strikingly more powerful, penetrating, and passionate look at metal than the one written by the guy [Tony Iommi] who arguably invented the genre...brave, engaging, and unique"— The Onion A/V Club "While the book is extensively researched and brings in a broad array of opinions from musicians, fans and academics, the most resonant moments can be found within Dawes'' own history."—Spinner "Insightful and provocative."— NOW Toronto "The book is half love letter to both black women who have paved the way and continue to pave the way, as well as the music that brought them there, and half unflinching real talk of the all unfortunate actualities of the casual to the not-so-casual racism that is embedded with the scene."—Persephone Magazine "This book needs to be mandatory reading for every new metal head."—Metal Army America "A wonderfully intimate memoir...critical insight abounds"— Philadelphia City Paper The women presented in What Are You Doing Here? are courageous, honest and without pretense—just like the best metal that ultimately unites them."—Albert Mudrian, editor-in-chief, Decibel "An intriguing reminder of how much we all want, need and deserve to belong to something that stimulates and validates us."— Terrorizer "Dawes tells an important story well and gives voice to the many black girls and women who are brave enough to let themselves be different."— LEO Weekly "She presents metal as a source of joy, an outlet for negative emotions, a physical release and catharsis. It is also an opportunity to embrace something that Dawes, and the women she interviews, love intensely, and therefore is also the narrative of the triumph of truth and happiness over the pressure of public perception."— Toronto Standard "Dawes brings a lot of experience, clear and concise writing and good journalism, and while she doesn't have any long-term solutions for bridging these deep and unfortunate valleys—through no fault of her own—she has still introduced the first step, which is opening our eyes and starting a dialogue."— SLUG "Jimi Hendrix is a god of rock guitarists, Living Color's Vernon Reid is considered the elder statesman of guitarship, and Laina Dawes is the cool-ass aunt of heavy metal."—Racialicious, "Courageous, honest, and without pretense"--Albert Mudrian, Decibel "The good, the bad, and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes"--Afro-Punk "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "A fantastic book."-- AOL Noisecreep, "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women''s voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "How exciting is this? The book tackles the good, the bad and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes."--Afropunk.com "A fantastic book"--AOL Noisecreep "Thoughtful and inspiring"-- Publishers Weekly "As journalist Laina Dawes has investigated in her 2012 book What Are You Doing Here? , women of colour have been especially marginalised by heavy metal''s hyper-masculine, white-dude culture."-- The Guardian "Dawes uses her sociological smarts to remind us that metal isn''t just disenfranchised white dudes'' music... it''s a way for all of us on the outside to feel the power."-- Revolver [4/5 stars] "Excellent"--About.com "Essential reading for those who have never felt the blow of intolerance, and for those who have felt it far too often...its themes are universal"--PopMatters "As the title suggests, Dawes has a compellingly idiosyncratic tale to tell about cultural identity and personal passion...[her] understandable difficulty is precisely what makes her struggle interesting."-- The Atlantic "Dawes has done the metal scene a great service...an important addition to every metal fan''s bookshelf"--MSN.com "Laina Dawes'' What Are You Doing Here? is a strikingly more powerful, penetrating, and passionate look at metal than the one written by the guy [Tony Iommi] who arguably invented the genre...brave, engaging, and unique"-- The Onion A/V Club "While the book is extensively researched and brings in a broad array of opinions from musicians, fans and academics, the most resonant moments can be found within Dawes'' own history."--Spinner "Insightful and provocative."-- NOW Toronto "The book is half love letter to both black women who have paved the way and continue to pave the way, as well as the music that brought them there, and half unflinching real talk of the all unfortunate actualities of the casual to the not-so-casual racism that is embedded with the scene."--Persephone Magazine "This book needs to be mandatory reading for every new metal head."--Metal Army America "A wonderfully intimate memoir...critical insight abounds"-- Philadelphia City Paper "The women presented in What Are You Doing Here? are courageous, honest and without pretense--just like the best metal that ultimately unites them."--Albert Mudrian, editor-in-chief, Decibel "An intriguing reminder of how much we all want, need and deserve to belong to something that stimulates and validates us."-- Terrorizer "Dawes tells an important story well and gives voice to the many black girls and women who are brave enough to let themselves be different."-- LEO Weekly "She presents metal as a source of joy, an outlet for negative emotions, a physical release and catharsis. It is also an opportunity to embrace something that Dawes, and the women she interviews, love intensely, and therefore is also the narrative of the triumph of truth and happiness over the pressure of public perception."-- Toronto Standard "Dawes brings a lot of experience, clear and concise writing and good journalism, and while she doesn''t have any long-term solutions for bridging these deep and unfortunate valleys--through no fault of her own--she has still introduced the first step, which is opening our eyes and starting a dialogue."-- SLUG "Jimi Hendrix is a god of rock guitarists, Living Color''s Vernon Reid is considered the elder statesman of guitarship, and Laina Dawes is the cool-ass aunt of heavy metal."--Racialicious, "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "A fantastic book."-- AOL Noisecreep, "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "How exciting is this? The book tackles the good, the bad and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes."--Afropunk.com "A fantastic book"--AOL Noisecreep "Thoughtful and inspiring"-- Publishers Weekly "As journalist Laina Dawes has investigated in her 2012 book What Are You Doing Here? , women of colour have been especially marginalised by heavy metal''s hyper-masculine, white-dude culture."-- The Guardian "Dawes uses her sociological smarts to remind us that metal isn''t just disenfranchised white dudes'' music... it''s a way for all of us on the outside to feel the power."-- Revolver [4/5 stars] "Excellent"--About.com "Essential reading for those who have never felt the blow of intolerance, and for those who have felt it far too often...its themes are universal"--PopMatters "As the title suggests, Dawes has a compellingly idiosyncratic tale to tell about cultural identity and personal passion...[her] understandable difficulty is precisely what makes her struggle interesting."-- The Atlantic "Dawes has done the metal scene a great service...an important addition to every metal fan's bookshelf"--MSN.com "Laina Dawes' What Are You Doing Here? is a strikingly more powerful, penetrating, and passionate look at metal than the one written by the guy [Tony Iommi] who arguably invented the genre...brave, engaging, and unique"-- The Onion A/V Club "While the book is extensively researched and brings in a broad array of opinions from musicians, fans and academics, the most resonant moments can be found within Dawes'' own history."--Spinner "Insightful and provocative."-- NOW Toronto "The book is half love letter to both black women who have paved the way and continue to pave the way, as well as the music that brought them there, and half unflinching real talk of the all unfortunate actualities of the casual to the not-so-casual racism that is embedded with the scene."--Persephone Magazine "This book needs to be mandatory reading for every new metal head."--Metal Army America "A wonderfully intimate memoir...critical insight abounds"-- Philadelphia City Paper "The women presented in What Are You Doing Here? are courageous, honest and without pretense--just like the best metal that ultimately unites them."--Albert Mudrian, editor-in-chief, Decibel "An intriguing reminder of how much we all want, need and deserve to belong to something that stimulates and validates us."-- Terrorizer "Dawes tells an important story well and gives voice to the many black girls and women who are brave enough to let themselves be different."-- LEO Weekly "She presents metal as a source of joy, an outlet for negative emotions, a physical release and catharsis. It is also an opportunity to embrace something that Dawes, and the women she interviews, love intensely, and therefore is also the narrative of the triumph of truth and happiness over the pressure of public perception."-- Toronto Standard "Dawes brings a lot of experience, clear and concise writing and good journalism, and while she doesn't have any long-term solutions for bridging these deep and unfortunate valleys--through no fault of her own--she has still introduced the first step, which is opening our eyes and starting a dialogue."-- SLUG "Jimi Hendrix is a god of rock guitarists, Living Color's Vernon Reid is considered the elder statesman of guitarship, and Laina Dawes is the cool-ass aunt of heavy metal."--Racialicious, "Courageous, honest, and without pretense"--Albert Mudrian, Decibel "Laina Dawes' What Are You Doing Here? is a strikingly more powerful, penetrating, and passionate look at metal than the one written by the guy [Tony Iommi] who arguably invented the genre...brave, engaging, and unique"-- The Onion A/V Club "The good, the bad, and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes"-- Afro-Punk "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "A fantastic book."-- AOL Noisecreep, "Courageous, honest, and without pretense"--Albert Mudrian, Decibel "Laina Dawes' What Are You Doing Here? is a strikingly more powerful, penetrating, and passionate look at metal than the one written by the guy [Tony Iommi] who arguably invented the genre...brave, engaging, and unique"-- The Onion A/V Club "What Are You Doing Here? is essential reading for those who have never felt the blow of intolerance, and for those who have felt it far too often."--PopMatters "Dawes has done the metal scene a great service, showing everyone that there's still a lot of work to do towards making metal truly welcoming to anyone who's interested in the music. We're not quite there yet, but What Are You Doing Here? is an excellent start, an important addition to every metal fan's bookshelf."--MSN.com "Thoughtful and inspiring"-- Publishers Weekly "Has the force of a powerful, eloquent typhoon... What Are You Doing Here? is fearless."-- Toronto Standard "The good, the bad, and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes."-- Afro-Punk "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "A fantastic book."--AOL Noisecreep, "Courageous, honest, and without pretense"--Albert Mudrian, Decibel "Laina Dawes' What Are You Doing Here? is a strikingly more powerful, penetrating, and passionate look at metal than the one written by the guy [Tony Iommi] who arguably invented the genre...brave, engaging, and unique"-- The Onion A/V Club "Dawes has done the metal scene a great service, showing everyone that there's still a lot of work to do towards making metal truly welcoming to anyone who's interested in the music. We're not quite there yet, but What Are You Doing Here? is an excellent start, an important addition to every metal fan's bookshelf."-- MSN.com "Has the force of a powerful, eloquent typhoon... What Are You Doing Here? is fearless."-- Toronto Standard "The good, the bad, and the ugly sides of being a black woman in the metal and punk scenes."-- Afro-Punk "In her debut book, music journalist and hardcore metal devotee Laina Dawes uncovers black women's voices and stories of participation in punk and metal."-- Vice "A fantastic book."-- AOL Noisecreep
